The question is do you hang and hunt each time or do you leave your stands out all year? For hanging and hunting, I prefer the 5 footer. Fits in my pack nice and is light. For leaving stands up all year, I use a big pole saw that is like 16 or 18 feet. I really think the 10 footer is kind of useless since the reach is kind of in the middle unless you don't have money to buy the 5 footer and a big pole saw. In that case, I would probably go with the 10 footer.