Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

Hunter to Hunter Confrontation!

Bowhuntingboy

New Member
For the last few weeks I have been patterning one particular buck. Each time I've been out I've adjusted accordingly. I have him figured out finally. He comes into this large alfalfa field 7 minutes before close each night I've been out this past week... and from the same trail too. I felt tonight was the night to move in for the ambush as the wind was perfect. I got out a little later than normal so I only had 2 hours. I get to the area that I have been hunting regularily on private land. I started dragging scent from the trail to my shooting lanes and all of a sudden I here a "Pssss". I look up and in this old wooden stand that is on the 'property line' there is a hunter. My father and I have exlusive rights to this whole tract and so I am a bit pissed that all of a sudden there is a guy hunting here. Not but two weeks ago my father and the landowner were walking the property with my mom and the farmer's wife and the farmer pointed out that wooden stand and how it was on his property and he was not happy about it. My adrenalin gave me the guts to go talk to the guy as calmly as I could and he turned the entire thing around and tried to make me feel as if I was the intruder... but I was the one with the permission, plus I had been hunting this area religiously the past few weeks. I tried to be polite but he did not take it that way at all. I hate any unfriendly confrontation like this. I ended the conversation as politely as possible and told him I would go hunt a couple hundred yards away, although he could see I was steaming. He said something along the lines of "Well you have that whole 80 acres to hunt and I'm hunting this little 10 acre plot so why do you have to hunt right here?" I didn't want to tell him about my buck and his scheduled arrival, of course. He felt he was right and I felt I was right. I don't want to go and make a stink about this to the landerowner but now I'm afraid this guy is going to go talk to the landowner and say "What kind of jerks do you let hunt on your land?" or something along those lines. To make things better, from my makeshift stand location I watched through my binoculars the big 8 come out of his trail at 7:03pm... a couple minutes ahead of schedule and I was not there to welcome him. I have an urge to right a letter and put it up on this stand to explain everything as politely as possible and to make him feel like he's the intruder
grin.gif
. I'm still steamin'. Any suggestions on what to do?
 
HE is in the wrong, why do you feel obligated to owe him anything? Sounds like he already had 2 strikes with the farmer by putting his stand on the fenceline.
 
Count to ten....maybe you better count to twenty.
cussing.gif
Do you know him? Are the property lines clearly defined? If so I'd definitely talk to the landowner about this guy. Tough call. Good Luck!
 
Yeah good luck, from what I understand you are completely right and there is no way you should back down to him. Find out who he is, talk to the landowner, and make sure he knows what is goin on.
 
Beware though, many times landowners will get a little squirrely if they think there is a confrontation brewing over their land or between neighbors, etc. Just be sure to approach it carefully so both parties are not welcomed back or something like that.
 
To answer some of you questions: I do not know who the guy is but he does know the landowner but does not have rights right now. He had permission for the plot that buts up to ours. And yes, my dad and I have exclusive rights except for certain times when turkey hunters are let in and for gun deer season when we only get the north 40, but right now we have all rights to hunt anywhere on the land. Just so I'm not too bias I should say that the stand is a big wooden box stand that has to have been there for years and years. I don't know if the landowner never knew about it, but he was mad about it being on his land two weeks ago. The hunter may be one of the gun hunters that has rights later in the year, but that does not give him the right to slip in now! But if I can be at all cooled down and able to see this guy's perspective he may think, "I've been hunting this stand for years..." And he did say he's been hunting this stand for years but I've been hunting this land for 6 or 7 years now and I've never seen another bowhunter. Even if he feels like he's been there for years I still feel I'm in the right as it seems most of you are agreeing and I know is true since, well, we have land rights. Wow, writing these posts is very theurputic
ooo.gif
. Wait, let me check, yep, I'm still steamin'.
 
Daver, your point is exactly what I'm worried about because this landowner is the kind of guy that is so nice and meek that he might be pissed to hear this even happened. Believe me, I wish it didn't.
 
Just a thought...

Maybe your dad should have asked the land owner if he'd mind if you "took" down that old wood box stand.

I would be POed as well! It's hard enough hunting whitetails as it is, but then to have another guy on the ground you believe is exclusively yours is tough.
 
Top Bottom