You can have the debate over here as to why you love or hate rage broadheads. I personally love them and havent lost a deer with them either. 1 deer out of the last 20 I've shot with rage havent been a pass thru and I watched her fall from the tree. A big part of it I believe is arrow selection. Do you know as a hunter you are shooting the correct spined arrow for the pounds you are pulling? That arrow is flexing in flight and you will not have the kinetic energy you need on impact with a light spined arrow pulling heavier pound bows. To each his own on broadhead selection but I wouldnt base your choice off a lost deer and bogus stories about people saying they hit the "boiler room" and didnt find it. If you hit the boiler room your deer will be dead a short distance away, plain and simple.