Are These the same deer?

[Brandon54626]

Are these 2 pictures of the same deer, I think they are but I thought I would come to the experts to see what you think.

 

[promise land]

I would say yes!

 

[jmoose]

my initial guess is no...not the same deer. the deer in the top photo has longer 2's than 3's and teh one in the bottom has longer 3's than 2's. i've been wrong before though.
both studs though!

 

[ShedderKG]

Nope...G2's are shorter that the G3's on the buck in 2nd pic. Couple nice ones!

 

[wapsiguy]

I say yes. The 2's in the second pic look shorter because of the angle. JMO

 

[jmoose]

can't be the same deer because the first deer has fuzzy antlers and the second has hard antlers.....

 

[Wiggleworm]

I say yes. The 2's in the second pic look shorter because of the angle. JMO

Agreed! the angle is playing tricks. Id say same deer.

 

[tyhambone]

No, velvet deer has shorter g2s than 3s, that 2nd buck has a ton of time length! Nice nice deer

 

[JakeWym]

Look the same to me....love those tall tined devils like that.

 

[Iowagiants90]

i would sa yes! and he looks like hes 3 if u gave hi abother year he would be a true iowa giant!

 

[bowtech1]

I would say no his g3s seem taller than twos in sec pic than in first but that's just me either way good lookin deer

 

[jlarson007]

I have no idea if that is the same deer but I would say it/them both are older then 3.5

 

[kingrooker]

I believe it is the same deer. Prob a 3 or 4 year old. Low 150s if I had to guess. Not much mass but good tine length. A borderline shooter depending on the land you hunt. I would take him. Thump! -{{{------->

 

[SaskGuy]

I also think it is the same deer. I think that simply because the odds of 2 bucks so similiar in terms of left antler, fairly equal 2's and 3's, long 4 and a 5 just seem pretty up there to me. I also think that the angle of the buck's head in the 2nd pic is making the length appear deceiving somewhat.