one of my knives had gouges in it and a flat edge. My buddies dad spent maybe a minute on the rough stone, very hard and very fast, then washed it off, and put it on the steel. it was hair cutting sharp!
i gutted 3 deer with it, skinned, quartered and processed one full deer, AND skinned 5 heads for euro mounts before it dulled!
and, he also taught me the importance of stroping, amazing what a piece of leather can do!
all im saying mud, is it can be done, and i JUST learned that....
this guy worked at a packing plant for 10 years and knows a thing or two about blades.....