Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

Michael Crossland

katy

Ballagh
I heard about this on the radio today:

This is from the Star Tribune:

OKLAHOMA CITY -— Michael Crossland didn't have much time to celebrate when he shot what may have been the largest whitetail deer ever killed in Oklahoma — a monster buck with a 31-point set of antlers worth thousands of dollars.

Instead, the antlers were seized by the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation and a charge of hunting without permission was filed against him. If convicted, he could be fined, face jail time, or both.

"It's been a heck of a mess,'' said Crossland, a 25-year-old farmer and rancher.

On Nov. 23, Crossland said, he was with a landowner's hired hand, who went to retrieve a four-wheeler and gave Crossland his rifle in case he spotted any big deer.

After walking around a bend on the west side of a creek, he spotted a doe, then saw the buck. After quickly loading the rifle, Crossland lined up the buck in his scope from about 70 yards away and dropped it with one shot.

Controversial trophyAssociated Press"I didn't know he was that big until he fell,'' Crossland said. "He fell and he rolled his head, and that's when I said, 'Oh my gosh.'''

But as word quickly spread about the huge deer, problems started to mount for Crossland.

Landowner Ryan Hunt, 26, requested the hunting charge, and if convicted Crossland faces a fine of up to $200 and 30 days in the county jail. It would then be up to the court to decide who gets to keep the antlers.

Crossland said he considered Hunt a friend, but they haven't spoken since the deer was shot. Crossland also said he's previously worked for the Hunt family and was told he could hunt on their property as long as he was with a family member or Greg Platner, the farmhand who was with Crossland on the day he shot the deer.

Hunt wouldn't specifically say whether he and Crossland were friends or whether he gave Crossland permission to hunt on his property.

"I'll say that our family has a lot of land, and it's always been known that no one hunts on our property without permission,'' Hunt said. "It doesn't matter if it's fishing, turkey or a little bitty doe.''

Although the antlers have not officially been scored under a standardized system, Yukon taxidermist Gerald Hillman measured the horns and said he's confident it will be a new state record for non-typical antlers, which refers to a lack of symmetry on each side of the rack.

Hillman estimated the antlers will score about 246 or 247 points. The current non-typical state record in Oklahoma is 240 3/8 from a whitetail in 2003.

Carl Eddy, the owner of Eddy's Northern Whitetails in Independence, Iowa, said the mounted head and horns would likely be worth between $20,000 and $30,000.

But Crossland said doesn't plan on selling and just wants them back.

"I want to keep it,'' he said. "That's a once-in-a-lifetime deal there.''

1146crossmanbuck.jpg
 
As land access gets tighter and the value of horns gets higher we can expect more of this kind of thing where one party or the other sees a potential huge windfall in the sale of antlers. I sure wish we could go back to the days when it was against the law to sell antlers. I know most don't agree with me but think about the reduction in poaching, fights over road kills, tresspassing, over harvest of bucks for dollars instead of enjoyment. Any way you cut it this Oklahoma thing is a bad deal.
 
You (not you) will find out who is your true friend if you shoot a big buck on their land. A real friend would be happy for you...not terminate the friendship. Bunch of crap that there are so many relationships ruined over a set of antlers.
I say the guy keeps his trophy, he followed the "rules" set by the landowner.
 
I agree with you bowmaker. If antlers were illegal to sell and there was no legal market value for them it might help avoid situations of this type. As things are now, money rules and things are out of control.
 
Does any one know why the law was changed to allow the sale of antlers? Was it to stop the back alley deals or what??
 
Sorry guys but I dissagree. As long as there are buyers there will be people willing to poach antlers or visa versa. It does not matter if they sell them openly or under the table, they will still be sold. In fact, probably 99.9% of all poached buck antlers that are sold are done under the table.
Some examples of laws not stopping illegal trade are ...
#1..Drugs. Highly illegal to sell or manufacture yet tons are sold daily.
#2..Post ban ivory. Allthough much of the bans have been lifted in the past few months, it was quite easy to obtain illegal ivory if you wanted it.
#3..Rhino Horn. Allthough illegal to sell in most countries and provences they have allmost become extinct due to the illegal trade in the horn.
#4..Bear gall bladder. The last I checked it was still illegal to sell bear gall bladders. Yet many bear are poached each year just for that purpose.
What I'm getting at here is there will allways be a market for deer antlers whether it's legal to sell or not.
We have plenty of laws in place allready to deal with poachers, sellers and buyers of illegal items. What we need more than anything is to get rid of the bleeding heart lawyers and judges that allow these low lifes to get off with just a slap on the wrist.

As for Mr. Crossland, if the story as he tells it is true then he's getting a bad deal.
It is one heck of a buck no matter who's in the right there.
 
Shovel, I'll second your post.

If laws prevented people from doing illegal things, our prisons would be empty.
 
Top Bottom