Buck Hollow Sporting Goods - click or touch to visit their website Midwest Habitat Company

Shooter Buck Botch Up!

Bowhuntingboy

New Member
Alright guys, your advice is needed big time here. Here's the story...

I've been after a certain shooter buck this year and I finally got a crack at him. I decided to move in on his bedding area tonight, since he is so nocturnal, to see if I can finally get a visual on him this year (I've pretty much been hunting his sign so far this season). I Lone Wolfed it on some dry ground between two cattail swamps where I know he moves between. He beds in the one to the right of my position. 2 does came out of the fresh trail I was set up on. They were in shooting range. I let them move on. I was hunting a ground stand with the Lone Wolf seat strapped onto the base of a tree since none of the trees were suitable for a quick climb (I didn't want to make too much noise pruning branches in prime season at 4:30 pm so near his bedding area).

15 minutes after the 2 does passed I spotted the brute. He was to my right emerging from the cattails. I could tell it was a buck but not if it was a shooter. He worked his way through some more brush and I got ready. When he emerged from the brush to my right I was jaw-dropped. He was a shooter by my standards, and the one I've been watching pre-season. I didn't analyze the rack too much because I was more worried about whether I should take this shot quick since he was heading out of the open soon... but a rough estimate: 9 to 10 pointer, not a wide rack but it was very tall! He'd probably score in the 140's (that's a shooter to me, especially in this high pressure area I hunt-last I saw of him was when he was in velvet). So I decided not to hesitate... I drew, aimed, judged the distance... and here's what went through my mind: "Dang... 45, maybe 50 yard shot... in dimming light... awe darn... but I might not get another chance at this nocturnal beast... I'm always too picky... just take the shot Robert..." Well, I took the shot... right on over his back she flew. The arrow crashed in the brush behind him and he took off into the cattails from where he'd come.

He had been looking toward me at the time I released, trying see what I was and he may have seen the arrow fly.

The question: How educated did I just make this deer!? I know I should have been patient since it is still pre-rut... and they're still in patterns. I am so mad at myself right now! I should've passed for a better shot. Anyway, it happened. Now I'm concerned about how I should continue to hunt this buck. Yeah, he spooked, of course. Should I let thinks cool down there for a week... then maybe do a decoy and rattling hunt next weekend... or should I wait longer? Any other advice on how I should proceed?
wall.gif
 
Pretty far shot in, what sounds like, poor light conditions. I would have passed the shot and tried another day. With the rut coming up around the corner he'll be on his feet more and more during the day. I doubt he'll go nocturnal but he's been educated that's for sure. Give it a few days and get back in there, just make sure that you hunt it on perfect winds. IF he comes back, he'll definately be spookier in that area. That's just one guys opinion.
 
Just to clarify too, I had been practicing 50 and 60 yard shots this year quite a bit and was getting pretty comfortable with them. I am usually very cautious about only taking sure shots... this may have reinforced that behavior! Just thought I would add this so you don't think I'm some guy flinging 60 yard shots all season long wounding deer. Taking this risky shot is outside of myself. Lesson learned...
 
Bad shot...low light, deer looking at you, 50 or 60 yards, bad shot all the way around bud. Better luck next time.
 
OK.....you already know it was a poor shot decision so I won't beat a dead horse. Main thing is that you learned from it.
If it was me, I'd probably stay out of the area for at least a week, maybe a little longer. Give him a chance to get stupid (seeking/chasing phase) and you might up your odds on him. Finding a tree you can get up 20 feet in wouldn't be a bad idea either.
Good luck with him, hope you get a second chance.
 
I agree with Critr. But get back in there today to prepare your tree and lanes, then leave it alone for awhile. Be sure not to drop branches over any trails.
 
Top Bottom