Manybooners,
I to will soon be a non-resident and I have to admit someday I will more than likely purchase land in the state of IA. I am disappointed I will be moving and yes it will be tough not hunting this great state every year, as I really enjoy sitting in the stand with some close friends and have really made some good friends with several farmers in the area. That being said, none of that would have been possible without the current regs, I have gained access to 1000+ acres of private land in IA because it is available for the common guy to get access beause we don't have lease issues, outfitters, etc etc. due to the current regulations from the IA DNR. Change these regulations and you will have another Golden Triangle on your hands, 70% of the ground in several counties will be leased and outfitted (just like Pike County) and sure a few more Booners might get posted and the state might be represented as the most likely to crack a booner, but the hunting will go to average at best, just like IL. No doubt there will still be some great places to hunt, but the opprotunity for the average hunter to knock on a door and gain access to ground through the offer of helping out a farmer or just because a the farmer is a heck of guy will be gone.
It has happened in great hunting states like IL and KS and if you change the laws the way you want them it will happen in IA too. IL started out with similar intentions as you are proposing, now they have left over NR tags every year, the leased land looks like cattle have been working the timbers from the number of hunters and many many areas have went from top notch hunting to piss poor hunting.
Do everyone a favor keep IA the best whitetail state in the country and leave the laws alone. IA is no different in my opinion than other states and areas that have made it difficult to draw tags such as AZ. AZ elk tag is a 6 year process unless you are very fortunate, no one complains because when the get there they know there is a great chance they will have a hunt of a lifetime.
Top notch hunting comes from top notch management, make the changes you want and I 10 years from now you will be bitching about the lack of quality hunting in IA.
Kratz