wjs,
Well......where do I begin?
First off, I'll commend you on having enough nerve to post and take credit for something that you know is probably going to tick a-lot of people off, especially on a "local" site such as this one. If you've been on this site very much, you'll know that there's a-lot of members who take the recent population issues very seriously, and that we are intent on not letting things get out of control. We as hunters can only do what we can do to try and persuade the law-makers of the state to see things as clearly as possible without the influence of money and big business. As hard as some of us try, it seems at times are voices and opinions fall on deaf ears, and that the monetary value of deer hunting in the state wins out over common sense and positive corrective actions.
Can you please tell me exactly what are the criteria for an overpopulated deer herd in our state? Is it a certain number of deer per square mile in a given county or number of road kills documented in a certain time frame? Are you getting your numbers based on mathematical calculations, or from farmers who are complaining about crop damage? My point being, never have I been asked by the IADNR for information regarding the outcome of my hunting seasons or wether or not I think I live in an area that is overpoopulated with deer, and to be totally honest with you, I have yet to see a DNR officer of any sort driving, glassing, or spotlighting anywhere near the area I live in. So, again I'll ask, if you're not getting any information from the locals in a given area, and the locals don't see you in a given area, how do you aquire the number of deer in a given area? You guys have thousands upon thousands of wonderful resources at your fingertips, yet I don't think you utilize them the way you should.
You say that controlling the population can be done two ways: Making people shoot does, or opening up other opportunities. How can the positives from the use of high power rifles in southern counties possibly out-weigh the negatives that can and will be associated with it? Who exactly is this an opportunity for? Will the IADNR provide added patrolling and policeing of these counties when season rolls around, or is everyone going to close their eyes and hope for the best. Who exactly benefits from an added early gun season at the end of November? Who is this an opportunity for? Does an overpopulated deer herd out-weigh the safety concerns that will arise when mixing gun hunters with bow hunters?
It seems to me that if the IADNR was really concerned about our ability to control the population in the state, they would of stopped charging for doe tags three of four years ago. If it was really a concern based on numbers, and not numbers of dollars, then why charge for something you're having problems getting rid of in the first place?
In my opinion, your goals can't be met by merely throwing out some more shotgun tags and placing high power rifles into the mix. If the IADNR and the legislators of this state are truely concerned with the number of deer in this state, they need to start working with the number one controlling factor that they already have available to them. Seems to me at times most of them do more talking then they do listening.
Hopefully Mr. Suchy, you haven't taken this too personally as it was not intended that way. Part of the problem is that some of us, myself included, aren't always informed completely about some of the issues. Thankfully for the members of this site the IBA plays a big part in trying to keep everyone informed of changes that are occuring annually, but the fact of the matter is, they can't be everywhere at once, even though they try to be. Hopefully you won't take some of our reply's to heart, mine included, but they come from a building frustration and sense of lack of teamwork that we all should be working on together to fulfill the goals of everyone, not just the ones who look at things from one side.
Once again, I hope you continue to remain an active member on this site, I'm sure there's a-lot we can learn from you, and maybe there's even a few things you can learn from us.
Thanks again,
CRITR